
Maybelline Sky High Mascara Review: Lengthening Worth It?
Our Maybelline Sky High mascara review covers its lengthening effect, flexible brush, wear, strengths and drawbacks, plus who should buy it.
Maybelline Sky High mascara: the short verdict
Maybelline Sky High is a lengthening mascara built around a flexible, tapered brush. It is the kind of everyday mascara that aims for a clean, fanned-out lash look rather than a heavy, false-lash finish: the formula coats and separates, and the wand is shaped to reach the smaller lashes at the inner and outer corners. The line includes a washable version and a waterproof version, which matters more than the shade name when you are buying.
It is a good fit if you want length, definition and easy removal from a high-street mascara. It is a less obvious fit if your priority is dense volume or a rigid brush that you can push through the lashes with force.
What you get in the tube
The product is a liquid mascara in a standard screw-top tube. The brush is the talking point: a flexible, tapered plastic wand that bends slightly as you apply it. That flexibility helps the tip follow the lash line and get into the corners, but it also means you need a lighter hand than you would use with a stiff wand. The washable version is the everyday choice; the waterproof version is the one for long days, tears, rain or events where you do not want to think about your mascara.
- Product type
- Lengthening liquid mascara
- Brush
- Flexible, tapered wand
- Versions
- Washable and waterproof
- Finish
- Lengthened and separated lashes
- Buildability
- Layer while the formula is still tacky
- Removal
- Warm water and gentle cleanser for washable; oil-based remover for waterproof
- Shelf life
- Follow the period-after-opening symbol on the tube
Strengths and weaknesses
What it does well
- Length is the headline: the tapered brush coats the tips and stretches the look of lashes.
- Good separation, so lashes look defined rather than stuck together.
- The flexible wand reaches inner and outer corners without smudging the eyelid.
- Buildable: one coat is neat, two give a more noticeable lengthened effect.
- The washable version removes with warm water and gentle pressure.
Where it falls short
- Volume is modest; if you want dense, false-lash impact, this is not that mascara.
- The bendy brush can feel unstable if you are used to a rigid wand.
- The washable formula is not the choice for tears, swimming or high humidity.
- The waterproof version needs a proper oil-based remover, so it is less convenient.
How it scores on the criteria that matter
Lengthening and separation are the priorities here; volume is the trade-off. The scores reflect where the product sits in its category, not lab measurements.
- Lengthening
- 4.5/5
- The tapered brush coats the tips and the formula builds without looking heavy.
- Separation
- 4.5/5
- Lashes stay defined when you wipe excess product off the wand first.
- Volume
- 3.0/5
- It adds thickness with more coats, but it stays in natural-to-defined territory.
- Brush control
- 3.5/5
- Excellent for corners; the flexible wand is less forgiving if you press hard.
- Ease of removal
- 4.5/5
- The washable version is straightforward; the waterproof version needs an oil-based remover.
- Everyday wear
- 3.5/5
- Comfortable for normal days; choose waterproof for humidity, tears or long events.
How to apply it for a cleaner, longer look
1. Curl first if you want lift
Curl lashes before mascara. Curling after mascara can stick lashes to the curler and make them clump.
2. Wipe the wand before the first coat
Draw the wand out and wipe the excess against the rim of the tube. Too much product on the brush is the quickest route to clumps.
3. Start at the roots
Place the wand at the base of the lashes and wiggle gently, then sweep upwards. Use a light hand with the flexible wand rather than pressing it into the lash line.
4. Use the tip for corners and lower lashes
Turn the wand and use the tapered tip on the inner and outer lashes. For the lower lash line, use only the tip and avoid loading it with fresh product.
5. Build while the formula is tacky
Add a second coat before the first has fully set. Waiting too long can make the second coat sit on top and look uneven.
6. Remove with the right product
Use warm water and a gentle cleanser for the washable version. For the waterproof version, use an oil-based eye-makeup remover and hold it against the lashes for a few seconds before wiping.
Who should buy it, and who should skip it
Sky High makes most sense for someone who already has a decent lash line and wants more length and definition without a heavy, spidery finish. It is also a sensible pick for people who find stiff brushes awkward: the tapered tip is easier to place on the inner and outer lashes, and the smaller head is less likely to catch the eyelid.
If your lashes are sparse and your main goal is density, the volume score tells the story: this is not the formula to buy first. If you need a mascara for swimming, a rainy commute or a wedding, buy the waterproof version, not the washable one.
Washable vs waterproof: which one to buy
The two versions share the brush and the lengthening approach, but they are built for different days.
The two versions share a brush but suit different days.
Consideration
Washable
- Best for
- Everyday wear and easy removal
- Removal
- Warm water and a gentle cleanser
- Feel on the lashes
- Lighter and more flexible
- Convenience
- Quicker to take off at night
- Weather
- Fine for normal indoor days
Waterproof
- Best for
- Long days, humidity, tears and events
- Removal
- An oil-based eye-makeup remover
- Feel on the lashes
- More set and resistant once dry
- Convenience
- Needs a dedicated remover and a little more care
- Weather
- The better bet for rain, heat and emotion
Common complaints and how to avoid them
Most of the complaints around Sky High come down to application or expectations rather than a fault in the product.
- Clumping: too much product on the wand is the usual cause. Wipe the wand and build in thin coats.
- A wobbly feel: the brush is designed to flex. Hold the wand lower down and use short strokes instead of pressing hard.
- Not enough volume: this is a lengthening mascara. If you want a dense, false-lash look, more coats will not turn it into a volumising formula.
- Smudging on the washable version: avoid rubbing your eyes and choose the waterproof version for humid days or events.
- Stubborn waterproof removal: use an oil-based remover, not water alone, and give it a few seconds to work.
Buying advice before you add it to your basket
Decide on the version first. If you need water resistance, look for the waterproof tube; if you remove makeup quickly at night and dislike oil-based removers, the washable version is the easier everyday buy.
Pick the shade for the look you want: black for a more defined lash line, brown-black for something softer. Availability varies by retailer, so check the shade name on the listing rather than assuming every store carries the full range.
Set your expectations around length, not volume. Sky High is at its best with one or two coats; a third coat adds weight more than density.
Mascara is an eye product, so replace it according to the period-after-opening symbol on the tube. If it smells different or the texture changes, stop using it.
Maybelline Sky High mascara: common questions
Is Maybelline Sky High mascara waterproof?
Does Sky High give a false-lash effect?
Can I use it on my lower lashes?
How do I remove the waterproof version?
Does it come in brown?
Is it suitable for sensitive eyes?
Related articles

Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk lipstick review
A clear-eyed review of Charlotte Tilbury's Pillow Talk lipstick: shade depth, matte vs satin finishes, wear, who it suits and what to check before buying.
One Product, Reviewed
e.l.f. Power Grip Primer review: does the tacky gel deliver?
A clear, tacky gel primer that grips foundation and keeps it in place — we weigh up hold, finish, feel, value and who it genuinely suits.
One Product, Reviewed
Laura Geller Makeup Review: Are the Baked Formulas Worth It?
A practical review of Laura Geller makeup, covering baked foundations, primers, finish, shade matching and who the line suits best.
One Product, Reviewed
L'Oréal True Match Foundation Review: A High-Street Staple
A clear-eyed look at L'Oréal True Match foundation: shade range, finish, coverage and staying power, plus who it suits and who should skip it.
One Product, Reviewed
MAC Studio Fix Fluid review: coverage, finish and who it suits
MAC Studio Fix Fluid reviewed: coverage, finish, wear and shade matching, plus who this matte, long-wearing foundation genuinely suits.
One Product, Reviewed
Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray Review
A practical review of Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray: who it suits, where it falls short and whether it deserves a place in your make-up bag.
One Product, Reviewed