Skip to content
Makeup to Makeout
Menu
Close-up of concealer dots under a woman's eye being tapped with a fingertip

Best Concealer: 5 Picks for Dark Circles and Blemishes

Our pick of the best concealers in the UK for dark circles, blemishes and dry under-eyes, from NARS and Tarte to Collection and Maybelline.

The quick answer: which concealer should you buy?

Concealer does the job foundation can't: it hides what you want hidden without putting a mask over the rest of your face. But "best" depends entirely on the job you're asking it to do, so here's the short version before the detail.

  • Best overall: NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer. Buildable medium-to-full coverage that flatters under the eyes and on blemishes alike. If you want one tube for everything, start here.
  • Best high-street buy: Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer. A fraction of the price and genuinely strong coverage for spots and redness.
  • Best for full coverage: Tarte Shape Tape Concealer. One layer hides pigmentation and breakouts, provided you use it sparingly.
  • Best for quick under-eye brightening: Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer. Light, blendable and easy to top up on the move.
  • Best for dry or mature under-eyes: Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer. A luminous finish that doesn't look flat or chalky.

The best concealers compared

All five are good. The differences come down to coverage, finish and how each one wears.

Concealer

Coverage

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
Medium to full, buildable
Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer
Medium to full
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
Full
Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer
Light to medium
Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer
Light to medium, buildable

Finish

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
Radiant satin
Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer
Natural matte
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
Matte
Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer
Natural, slightly dewy
Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer
Luminous

Best for

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
Under-eyes and blemishes alike
Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer
Spots, redness and long days
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
Pigmentation, redness and breakouts
Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer
Quick under-eye brightening
Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer
Dry or lined under-eyes

Price position

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
Mid-range
Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer
High street
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
Mid-range
Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer
High street
Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer
Premium

1. NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer: best overall

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer

Best overall

Rating 4.8/5

The one we'd hand to almost anyone. It's a liquid with a creamy, slightly radiant finish that sits between a satin and a glow, and the coverage builds from a light veil to something that genuinely blurs redness and shadows — without the flat, painted-on look full-coverage formulas often have.

It's the most versatile on this list. A small dot tapped under the eye is enough for a workday; two thin layers handle a spot or a patch of pigmentation. It blends with a finger, a damp sponge or a small dense brush, and on normal and dry skin it sets well enough without powder. On oily skin, a light dusting keeps it in place.

If you only buy one concealer, make it this one.

Why we rate it

  • Buildable from sheer to full without going cakey
  • Radiant finish works under the eyes and on blemishes
  • Blends easily with fingers, sponge or brush
  • Wears comfortably through a long day on normal and dry skin

Worth knowing

  • The most expensive of the everyday picks here
  • Over-applying makes it settle into fine lines
  • The radiant finish can look shiny on very oily skin

2. Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer: best high-street buy

Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer

Best high-street buy

Rating 4.5/5

A British high-street staple for years, and it still earns its place. It's thicker and more matte than the NARS pick, which is exactly why it works on blemishes, redness around the nose and the odd breakout: a tiny amount covers far more than you'd expect from a tube at this price.

Where it's less forgiving is under the eyes. The matte finish can emphasise dryness and fine lines, so keep the layer there very thin and set it with the smallest amount of powder. Used as a spot concealer, it's hard to beat for the money — and it's the one you won't mind repurchasing every few months.

Why we rate it

  • Excellent coverage for the price
  • Matte finish holds up well on oily skin
  • A little goes a long way, so a tube lasts
  • Easy to find on the high street

Worth knowing

  • The matte finish can look dry under the eyes
  • Needs a light hand or it turns cakey
  • Small tube that runs out quickly with daily use

3. Tarte Shape Tape Concealer: best for full coverage

Tarte Shape Tape Concealer

Best for full coverage

Rating 4.3/5

The full-coverage option. It's a thick, opaque liquid with a matte-ish finish: one tap covers a blemish, a patch of redness or a scar, and it stays put through a long day without much babysitting.

That same opacity is why it isn't the most natural choice under the eyes. If your under-eye area is dry or lined, sheer it out with a dot of eye cream or press it in with a damp sponge, or keep it strictly for the spots that need it. A full-coverage formula also shows a shade mismatch more starkly than a sheer one, so take your time over the shade.

Why we rate it

  • Hides redness, spots and pigmentation in one layer
  • Long-wearing and hard to shift once set
  • Excellent for spot-concealing rather than all-over use

Worth knowing

  • Can look heavy under the eyes if you use too much
  • Matte finish is unforgiving on dry or lined skin
  • A shade mismatch is much more obvious than with a sheer formula

4. Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer: best for quick brightening

Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer

Best for quick under-eye brightening

Rating 4.2/5

The one to reach for when you want to look awake in thirty seconds. The twist-up tube has a built-in sponge applicator, so you click, dab under the eye and blend with a fingertip — no brush required, which makes it the easiest of the five to use on the train.

Coverage is light to medium and the texture is thin and blendable, which makes it very good at brightening the under-eye area and softening redness without looking like makeup. It won't hide a deep spot or serious pigmentation. The sponge tip divides opinion: convenient, but not the most hygienic applicator and awkward to clean properly.

Why we rate it

  • Fastest to apply of the five
  • Light, blendable texture that looks like skin
  • Great for a no-makeup makeup look
  • Affordable enough to keep in a bag

Worth knowing

  • Light to medium coverage only
  • The built-in sponge applicator is hard to keep clean
  • The twist mechanism can dispense more than you need

5. Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer: best for dry under-eyes

Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer

Best for dry or lined under-eyes

Rating 4.4/5

Built for the under-eye area. The texture is creamy and emollient, the finish is luminous, and it melts into skin rather than sitting on top of it — which is what you want if the skin under your eyes is dry or simply prone to looking tired.

Coverage is light to medium and buildable, so it evens out shadows and redness without going opaque, and it's the pick for anyone who finds matte concealers ageing. The trade-offs are the price and the coverage ceiling: it won't cover a dark birthmark or a fresh breakout, and on oily skin you'll want to powder it or it will migrate by lunchtime.

Why we rate it

  • Luminous, skin-like finish that doesn't look flat
  • Blends beautifully with fingertips
  • Comfortable on dry and mature under-eyes
  • Layers well over foundation and SPF

Worth knowing

  • Premium price
  • Light to medium coverage won't hide dark spots
  • Needs setting powder on oily skin

How to choose a concealer that suits your skin

Concealer is a small purchase with a lot of variables. These are the ones that actually change how happy you are with the result.

  • Shade. Match your foundation for spots and blemishes; for the under-eye area, half a shade lighter or a peachy tone neutralises blue-toned shadows. Swatch on the jaw and check in daylight.
  • Coverage. Sheer formulas look more like skin; full-coverage ones hide more but show texture. Decide whether you're covering a shadow or a spot.
  • Finish. Matte formulas grip oily skin and blemishes; radiant ones flatter dry or lined under-eyes. Most people need one of each, not one tube for everything.
  • Texture. Liquids with a doe-foot applicator are the most versatile. Creams in a pot or stick suit spot-concealing and dryness but can be heavy under the eyes.
  • Wear. Anything under your eyes moves every time you blink, so a formula that sets to a soft finish is a bonus. Oily skin will still need a light powder.
  • Shade range. If you sit at either end of the depth scale or have a strong undertone, check the range before you fall for the formula.
Shade match
5.0/5
Nothing else matters if the shade is wrong. Look at the undertone, not just the depth.
Coverage
4.5/5
A shadow under the eye needs far less coverage than a blemish or a patch of pigmentation.
Finish
4.0/5
Matte for spots and oily skin, radiant for dry or lined under-eyes. One tube rarely does both well.
Comfort under the eyes
4.5/5
Thin, flexible formulas crease less than thick ones. Heavy coverage is where cakiness starts.
Wear and setting
4.0/5
Look for something that sets to a soft finish rather than sliding around all afternoon.
Value
3.5/5
A cheap tube that creases is worse value than a pricier one you actually finish.

How to apply concealer without creasing

Most concealer complaints are application problems rather than product problems.

  • Use less than you think. One dot per under-eye area is usually enough; add a second layer only where you can still see the shadow.
  • Tap, don't drag. A fingertip, a damp sponge or a small dense brush pressed into the skin blends better than a sweeping motion, which moves product around and leaves streaks.
  • Colour correct first if you need to. For very dark circles, a peach or orange corrector underneath means you need far less concealer on top.
  • Set only where it creases. A small amount of finely milled powder pressed into the inner corner and the crease line stops movement without flattening the whole area.
  • Skip powder on dry skin. If your under-eyes are dry, powder can make texture more visible; a setting spray is often the better last step.

The verdict

Concealer questions, answered

Should concealer be lighter than my foundation?
For the under-eye area, half a shade to a full shade lighter — or a peachy tone — helps cancel shadows. For spots and redness, match your foundation exactly, or the concealer will show up as a pale dot.
Can I wear concealer without foundation?
Yes. A light, blendable concealer on redness and under the eyes is often all you need for a no-makeup look. Blend the edges into bare skin and set only where it creases.
Why does my concealer crease under my eyes?
Usually too much product, or a formula that's too thick for the area. Use a thinner layer, tap it in rather than dragging, and press a small amount of powder into the crease line.
Do I apply concealer before or after foundation?
After. Foundation evens out the base, then concealer goes only where you still need it, which keeps the overall look lighter. The exception is a colour corrector, which goes underneath both.
How long does an opened concealer last?
Check the period-after-opening symbol on the tube — for most liquid concealers it's between six and twelve months. If the texture separates, the smell changes or it starts to irritate, replace it.
Can I use concealer as an eyeshadow base?
A thin layer of a matte, non-oily concealer can work as a base, but the radiant and emollient formulas here will make eyeshadow slip. Set it with a little translucent powder first.

Related articles