Skip to content
Makeup to Makeout
Menu
Makeup artist applying eyeshadow to a woman

Best Setting Spray: 5 Picks for Makeup That Stays Put

We compare five setting sprays for oily, dry and mature skin, from Urban Decay to NYX, so you can pick the right finish and mist for your makeup.

The quick answer: which setting spray is right for you?

If you want one spray that works for most skin types and most long days, start with Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray. It is the safest all-rounder: lightweight, not tight or sticky, and it helps makeup survive heat, humidity and a full day at work.

  • Best overall: Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray
  • Best for dry or mature skin: Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray
  • Best prep-and-set multitasker: MAC Prep + Prime Fix+
  • Best budget pick for oily skin: NYX Professional Makeup Setting Spray Matte Finish
  • Best fine mist on a budget: e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist

How the five setting sprays compare

Finish, skin type and the main trade-off for each pick.

Setting spray

Best for

Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray
Most skin types and long days
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray
Dry or mature skin
MAC Prep + Prime Fix+
Prepping and setting in one
NYX Professional Makeup Setting Spray Matte Finish
Oily skin on a budget
e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist
A fine everyday mist

Finish

Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray
Natural, skin-like
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray
Soft-focus, slightly luminous
MAC Prep + Prime Fix+
Dewy and fresh
NYX Professional Makeup Setting Spray Matte Finish
Matte
e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist
Natural

Skin type

Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray
All, especially combination
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray
Dry, normal, mature
MAC Prep + Prime Fix+
Normal to dry
NYX Professional Makeup Setting Spray Matte Finish
Oily, combination
e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist
All

Watch out

Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray
Premium price
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray
Weaker shine control
MAC Prep + Prime Fix+
Less mattifying
NYX Professional Makeup Setting Spray Matte Finish
Nozzle can be less fine
e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist
Not the longest-wearing

The premium picks: Urban Decay, Charlotte Tilbury and MAC

Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray

Best overall

Rating 4.8/5

The one to choose if you want a setting spray that suits most routines and most skin types. All Nighter has a fine, even mist and a finish that looks like skin rather than a film. It is particularly useful for long days, warm rooms and events where makeup needs to stay put without adding shine. It layers well over foundation and powder and does not feel tight, which is why it is a popular kit staple. The main drawback is the price: you pay for the reliability.

Why it wins

  • Works across most skin types
  • Lightweight, non-sticky finish
  • Helps makeup survive long days
  • Fine mist that does not soak the face

Worth knowing

  • Premium price
  • Not the most mattifying option for very oily skin

Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray

Best for dry or mature skin

Rating 4.6/5

A soft-focus setting spray that flatters dry, mature and normal skin. The mist is very fine, and the finish is comfortable rather than tight, so it is a good choice if mattifying sprays tend to make your face feel dry or emphasise texture. It sets makeup without flattening a glowy base, and it works well over cream and powder products. It is expensive, and oily skin may still need powder through the day.

Why it wins

  • Soft-focus finish flatters texture
  • Comfortable on dry or mature skin
  • Very fine, even mist
  • Does not make makeup look flat

Worth knowing

  • High price
  • Not enough shine control for very oily skin

MAC Prep + Prime Fix+

Best prep-and-set multitasker

Rating 4.5/5

Fix+ is less of a heavy-duty setting spray and more of a flexible mist. Use it before makeup to add moisture, after makeup to melt powder into the skin, or on a brush to make shimmer eyeshadow apply more intensely. It leaves a fresh, dewy finish and suits normal to dry skin that wants a setting mist without a matte look. It will not hold up as well as a dedicated long-wear spray on a hot, oily day, and the dewiness is not for everyone.

Why it wins

  • Three uses: prep, set and intensify makeup
  • Dewy finish softens powder
  • Good for normal to dry skin
  • Works well with cream and powder formulas

Worth knowing

  • Less mattifying and long-wearing
  • Dewy finish can look too shiny on oily skin

The budget picks: NYX and e.l.f.

NYX Professional Makeup Setting Spray Matte Finish

Best budget pick for oily skin

Rating 4.4/5

If shine is your main problem, this is the best low-cost option. The matte finish helps take down oiliness and keeps makeup looking fresher for longer, which makes it a sensible choice for oily and combination skin. It is lightweight and easy to layer over powder. The trade-off is the nozzle: the mist can be less fine than premium sprays, so hold it further away and use short bursts to avoid wet patches. It can also feel slightly tight if you over-apply.

Why it wins

  • Mattifies without a heavy feel
  • Good value for oily skin
  • Easy to find on the high street
  • Layers well over powder

Worth knowing

  • Nozzle can spray unevenly
  • Can feel tight if you use too much

e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist

Best fine mist on a budget

Rating 4.3/5

The draw here is the mist itself: it is very fine, so it settles evenly and does not leave large droplets on your makeup. That makes it a good everyday spray for normal and combination skin, and a handy option if you dislike the wet feeling of heavier setting sprays. It is not the most hard-wearing formula in this list, so it is better for workdays and short events than a long, hot day. The packaging is basic, but the performance is impressive for the price.

Why it wins

  • Very fine, even mist
  • Lightweight and comfortable
  • Affordable everyday option
  • Good for normal and combination skin

Worth knowing

  • Not as long-wearing as premium sprays
  • Basic packaging

How to choose a setting spray

Start with your skin type and the finish you want, then think about how long you need makeup to last. A setting spray cannot fix a base that is already separating, so match the formula to your routine.

  • Skin type: Oily skin benefits from a mattifying formula; dry skin needs something comfortable that will not emphasise flakes; combination skin can usually wear either.
  • Finish: Natural, matte, dewy or soft-focus. The finish should work with your foundation, not fight it.
  • Wear time: If you need makeup to survive a full working day, choose a dedicated long-wear spray rather than a prep mist.
  • Mist quality: A fine, even mist is easier to control. A coarse spray can leave droplets and disturb foundation.
  • Layering: Look for a spray that sets powder without making it look chalky.
  • Value: A budget spray can be excellent, but check whether you need extra powder or blotting later.
Finish matches your skin type
5.0/5
The most important factor: a matte spray on dry skin can look patchy, and a dewy spray on oily skin can slide.
Longevity
5.0/5
If you need all-day wear, prioritise a dedicated setting spray over a prep mist.
Mist quality
4.5/5
A fine nozzle distributes product evenly and stops droplets ruining foundation.
Layering over powder
4.0/5
The best sprays melt powder into the skin without making it look heavy.
Value for money
4.0/5
You do not need to spend a lot, but premium sprays often have finer nozzles and more reliable wear.

How to apply setting spray properly

Setting spray works best in thin layers. Shake the bottle, hold it about an arm's length from your face, and mist in a crosshatch pattern: once across, once down, then once diagonally. Keep your eyes closed and your mouth relaxed. Let it dry naturally rather than fanning your face, which can push product into fine lines.

If you have used a lot of powder, mist once to melt the powder, wait for it to dry, then add a second light layer only where you need it. For a dewier finish, use a prep mist like MAC Fix+ before makeup and a setting spray afterwards. For oily skin, blot first and then mist; spraying over shine can make it look wet rather than matte.

Common setting spray mistakes

  • Spraying too close. Holding the bottle near your face leaves wet patches and can disturb foundation. Move it further back and use short bursts.
  • Using a mattifying spray on dry skin. It can emphasise flakes and make makeup look flat. Dry skin usually does better with a hydrating or soft-focus mist.
  • Skipping powder completely. Setting spray is a topcoat, not a substitute for oil control. Very oily skin usually needs a light powder under the mist.
  • Misting over unblended makeup. If foundation is already patchy, setting spray will seal the patchiness in place.
  • Over-applying. More product does not mean longer wear; it can make makeup feel tight or look shiny.

The verdict: which setting spray should you buy?

Setting spray FAQs

Is setting spray the same as fixing spray?
Not always. A setting spray is usually the final mist that helps makeup last, while a fixing spray is often a lighter mist used to melt powder or refresh makeup. Brands sometimes use the terms interchangeably, so check the product description.
Can I use setting spray on bare skin?
Yes, but it will not do much. Setting spray is designed to seal makeup; on bare skin it acts more like a light refreshing mist. If you want hydration before makeup, use a prep mist instead.
How long should setting spray last?
It depends on the formula and your skin type. A dedicated long-wear spray can help makeup last through a working day, while a light prep mist may only give a few hours of freshness. Oily skin may still need blotting or powder.
Why does my setting spray make my makeup patchy?
Usually because the spray is too coarse, you are holding it too close, or the layers underneath are not compatible. Hold the bottle further away, use a light hand, and let each layer dry before adding more.
Can setting spray replace powder?
No. Powder controls shine and sets cream products; setting spray seals the finished look. Oily skin usually needs both, while dry skin may prefer a light mist and minimal powder.
Do I need to shake setting spray?
Most formulas benefit from a quick shake before use, especially those with powders or bi-phase liquids. Check the bottle instructions, as some mists are ready to use as they are.

Related articles