Skip to content
Makeup to Makeout
Menu
Woman in white robe applying mascara to her lashes

Best Waterproof Mascara: 5 Picks That Stay Put All Day

Five waterproof mascaras compared for smudge resistance, curl hold and easy removal, from high-street picks to premium tubes — plus removal tips.

The quick answer

Waterproof mascara has one job — staying put through rain, tears, a sweaty commute and the odd cry — but the good ones also hold a curl and don't turn your lashes into clumps. We looked at the waterproof tubes most widely stocked on the high street and at beauty counters, and weighed up formula, brush, wear and how easy each one is to take off.

If you want one tube that does everything well without spending much, Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Waterproof is the pick for most people.

  • Best overall: Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Waterproof Mascara
  • Best for volume: L'Oréal Paris Lash Paradise Waterproof Mascara
  • Best for drama: Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara
  • Best premium: Lancôme Monsieur Big Waterproof Mascara
  • Best for sensitive eyes: Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara

At a glance: how the five compare

Five waterproof mascaras, compared on the things that decide whether you'll repurchase.

Mascara

Best for

Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Waterproof
Best overall
L'Oréal Paris Lash Paradise Waterproof
Best for volume
Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof
Best for drama
Lancôme Monsieur Big Waterproof
Best premium
Clinique High Impact Waterproof
Best for sensitive eyes

Brush

Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Waterproof
Double-hook wand
L'Oréal Paris Lash Paradise Waterproof
Wavy fibre brush
Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof
Hourglass brush
Lancôme Monsieur Big Waterproof
Large soft brush
Clinique High Impact Waterproof
Tapered bristle brush

Finish

Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Waterproof
Lifted and separated
L'Oréal Paris Lash Paradise Waterproof
Full and soft
Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof
Dense and black
Lancôme Monsieur Big Waterproof
Bold but flexible
Clinique High Impact Waterproof
Clean definition

Removal

Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Waterproof
Oil-based cleanser
L'Oréal Paris Lash Paradise Waterproof
Cleansing balm
Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof
Oil-based cleanser
Lancôme Monsieur Big Waterproof
Bi-phase remover
Clinique High Impact Waterproof
Oil cleanser, gently

None of these are the sort of mascara you can swipe off with a face wipe. Budget for a proper oil-based cleanser or a cleansing balm alongside whichever tube you buy — it's part of the cost of wearing waterproof.

The five best waterproof mascaras

Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Waterproof Mascara

Best overall

Rating 4.6/5

A waterproof version of Maybelline's lash-lift formula, with a double-hook wand that catches lashes at the root and pulls them upwards. The formula goes on wet, so it coats quickly, then sets to a flexible finish that resists smudging on the upper lid.

It wins on balance: you get lift and separation rather than pure bulk, so lashes look longer without shouting mascara. It's the tube to buy if you want one product for the office, the gym and the odd rainy walk home.

Why we rate it

  • Holds a lifted shape through a long day
  • Separates well, with little clumping on the first coat
  • High-street price and easy to find in the UK
  • The waterproof version keeps the character of the original

Watch out for

  • Can feel slightly stiff once fully set
  • A rushed second coat clumps
  • Not the most volumising of the five

L'Oréal Paris Lash Paradise Waterproof Mascara

Best for volume

Rating 4.4/5

Lash Paradise is the volume choice. The wavy, fibre-packed brush loads lashes from root to tip and builds a soft, full fan rather than spiky definition, and the waterproof version keeps that fullness without the flaking the washable one can develop.

It suits fine or sparse lashes that need thickness fast. The trade-off is control: the brush is big, so it's easy to print product onto the eyelid, and the formula needs a proper oil-based cleanser to shift.

Why we rate it

  • Noticeable volume in one or two coats
  • Soft fibre brush fans lashes outward
  • Holds up well in heat and humidity
  • Good value for the amount of product in the tube

Watch out for

  • Big brush takes practice on short or hooded lids
  • Clumps if you layer before the first coat sets
  • Leaves residue if you only use a foaming cleanser

Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara

Best for drama

Rating 4.3/5

The waterproof take on Too Faced's best-known mascara uses the same hourglass brush, wider through the middle to lift the centre lashes and narrow at the ends for the inner and outer corners. The result is the most dramatic lash of the five: dense, black and slightly fanned.

It's the one for a night out, a wedding or a long day where you can't touch up — it stays put through tears. It's also the heaviest look here, so it's a deliberate choice rather than an everyday default.

Why we rate it

  • Big, dense, properly dramatic lashes
  • Hourglass brush reaches corner lashes
  • Genuinely tear-proof once it has set

Watch out for

  • Very easy to overload
  • Can look heavy for daytime wear
  • Premium price for a mascara you replace often

Lancôme Monsieur Big Waterproof Mascara

Best premium

Rating 4.5/5

Monsieur Big is the premium pick, built around a large, soft-bristled brush that coats a lot of lash in a single pass. The formula is thick and black with a soft-set finish, so lashes stay flexible rather than crispy — which is where cheaper volumising formulas usually fall down.

What earns it the price is the way it layers: three coats still read as lashes rather than spiders' legs. The brush really is large, though, so anyone with small or very hooded eyes will find the corners fiddly.

Why we rate it

  • Layers repeatedly without clumping
  • Soft-set finish keeps lashes flexible
  • Strong volume in a single coat

Watch out for

  • Large brush is awkward on small eyes
  • The most expensive of the five
  • Needs a bi-phase or oil remover, not micellar alone

Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara

Best for sensitive eyes

Rating 4.2/5

Clinique's waterproof High Impact is the gentlest of the group. The tapered brush is smaller than the others, which makes it the easiest to control on lower lashes and on short lashes, and the formula gives clean definition rather than bulk.

It's the sensible choice if your eyes stream at the first sign of a heavy formula, or if you wear contact lenses and want something light on the lash line. Just don't expect Lash Paradise levels of volume — this is a definition product, not a drama product.

Why we rate it

  • Small tapered brush gives precise control
  • Clean, clump-free definition
  • Comfortable on the lower lash line
  • Lightweight feel on the lashes

Watch out for

  • Modest volume
  • Needs two coats for an evening look
  • Premium price for a subtle result

What actually matters when you choose

Smudge resistance
5.0/5
The whole point. Think about how oily your lids get and whether you wear cream eye products underneath.
Curl hold
4.5/5
Waterproof formulas are heavier, so a good one sets the lift instead of dragging it back down.
Brush size and shape
4.0/5
A tapered or smaller brush is easier on short, straight and hooded lashes; big fibre brushes build volume faster.
Ease of removal
4.0/5
Anything genuinely waterproof needs oil. If you know you won't bother, a tubing formula may suit you better.
Layerability
3.5/5
Whether a second or third coat stays like lashes rather than clumps is where cheap tubes usually give themselves away.

Two practical checks before you commit to a tube:

  • Look at the wand, not just the claim. Waterproof formulas are stiffer, so the brush does more of the work. Small eyes and straight lashes do better with a tapered or curved wand.
  • Decide how you'll take it off. If you already use a cleansing balm or an oil cleanser, any of these five will come away cleanly. If you rely on micellar water and cotton pads, expect to rub — which is the thing that actually damages lashes.

Waterproof, water-resistant and tubing: what's the difference?

The labels aren't interchangeable, and shops use them loosely.

Water-resistant mascaras cope with a bit of rain, sweat or a tear or two, but they'll still smudge if you properly cry or swim. They're easier to remove and kinder to lashes day to day.

Waterproof means what it says: the formula sets harder and resists water, sweat and tears far better. It's the right choice for weddings, holidays, sport and anyone with oily lids or watery eyes.

Tubing mascaras wrap each lash in polymer tubes rather than painting on pigment. They don't smudge at all, and they come off with warm water and gentle pressure — but they give a thinner, more separated lash and offer little volume.

If you want volume and a curl that lasts, choose waterproof. If you want the easiest possible removal, tubing is worth a look.

Applying and removing it without losing lashes

  • Curl first, mascara second. Once waterproof mascara sets, a curler will kink and can snap the lash.
  • Wipe the wand. Excess product on the tip is what causes smudges on the lid and clumps at the tips.
  • Build in thin coats. Two light coats set better than one heavy one, and they flake less.
  • Keep cream off the lash line. A rich eye cream directly under the lashes will break down any mascara, waterproof or not.
  • Remove the same day. Sleeping in it dries the lashes out and makes the next morning's removal far rougher.

The verdict

Frequently asked questions

Will waterproof mascara hold a curl on straight lashes?
Generally yes, and better than a washable formula. The stiffer waterproof texture sets the lash in the shape you've curled it into, so the lift lasts longer. Curl before you apply, never after.
Can I wear waterproof mascara with lash extensions?
It's usually advised against. Oil-based removers — which you need for waterproof mascara — break down the adhesive used for extensions, so you risk losing bonds. Check with your technician first.
Why has my waterproof mascara started to flake?
The usual culprits are too many coats, applying over a rich eye cream, or a tube that's been open too long and has dried out. Flaking is a sign to replace it rather than to add more layers.
Does micellar water remove waterproof mascara?
Not reliably. Standard micellar water struggles with waterproof formulas, and the rubbing needed to make it work is what damages lashes. Use an oil-based cleanser, a cleansing balm or a bi-phase eye makeup remover instead.
Is waterproof mascara suitable for contact lens wearers?
Many people wear it without issue, but the formula sits close to the eye and flakes can irritate. A lighter, finely milled formula with a small brush — such as Clinique High Impact Waterproof — is generally easier to live with than a heavy volumising one.

Related articles