Skip to content
Makeup to Makeout
Menu
Woman in towel applying mascara at bathroom mirror

Best Mascara Picks for Length, Volume and Sensitive Eyes

Five mascaras worth knowing about, from Maybelline Sky High to Clinique High Impact, plus how to choose the right formula and brush for your lashes.

The quick answer

There is no single best mascara for everyone, because the wand that gives you fluttery separation will not give you the dense, false-lash volume someone else is after. What you can do is match the formula and brush to the result you actually want.

  • Best overall: Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High — buildable length and volume, easy to find on the high street, and a flexible tapered brush that separates as it coats.
  • Best for drama: Too Faced Better Than Sex — plush, dense volume from the first coat.
  • Best for length and definition: Benefit They're Real! Magnet — a domed brush with a tip that reaches the inner and outer corners.
  • Best for sensitive eyes: Clinique High Impact — comfortable, ophthalmologist-tested and easy to remove.
  • Best for precision: L'Oréal Paris Telescopic — a comb-style wand that separates even short, stubborn inner lashes.

The five best mascaras at a glance

How the five compare on purpose, finish and wand shape.

Mascara

Best for

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High
Everyday length with buildable volume
Too Faced Better Than Sex
Dramatic, dense volume
Benefit They're Real! Magnet
Length and separation
Clinique High Impact
Sensitive eyes and contact lenses
L'Oréal Paris Telescopic
Precision and clump-free definition

Finish

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High
Fanned-out and wide-awake
Too Faced Better Than Sex
Full and plush, slightly clumpy if over-layered
Benefit They're Real! Magnet
Defined, extended tips
Clinique High Impact
Soft, natural volume
L'Oréal Paris Telescopic
Clean and separated

Wand

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High
Flexible tapered brush with short and long bristles
Too Faced Better Than Sex
Large hourglass-shaped brush
Benefit They're Real! Magnet
Domed brush with a narrow precision tip
Clinique High Impact
Traditional bristle brush
L'Oréal Paris Telescopic
Slim comb-style precision wand

The biggest difference between these five is not price but brush geometry. Fatter brushes deposit more formula per stroke, which is why they build volume quickly and clump just as quickly; slimmer brushes and combs coat each lash individually, so they take longer but give a tidier result.

Best overall: Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara

Best overall

Rating 4.5/5

Sky High is the sensible starting point if you want a bit of everything: visible length, enough volume that lashes do not look sparse, and a finish that still reads as your own lashes rather than a set of falsies. The tapered, flexible brush has short bristles at the tip for the inner and outer corners and longer ones through the middle, so it coats and separates in the same stroke. Two thin coats give a fanned-out, wide-awake look; a third starts to look heavier. Both washable and waterproof versions exist, which makes it easy to keep one in a gym bag and one in a wedding-day kit. It is not the most dramatic formula here, and if your lashes are very fine you may want a primer underneath.

Why it wins

  • Buildable length that shows from the first coat
  • Tapered brush separates lashes instead of bunching them
  • Available in washable and waterproof versions
  • Easy to find on the high street and in travel sizes

Watch out for

  • Volume is buildable rather than dramatic
  • The waterproof version needs an oil-based cleanser to remove

Best for dramatic volume: Too Faced Better Than Sex

Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara

Best for dramatic volume

Rating 4.5/5

Better Than Sex is the pick when volume is the entire brief. The hourglass-shaped brush holds a lot of formula and pushes it through the lashes, giving that dense, plush, almost fuzzy lash line that photographs well in low light. One coat is usually enough for an evening out; a second adds density but also adds risk of clumping at the tips, so comb through with a clean spoolie while the formula is still tacky. The original is not waterproof — a waterproof version exists — and it takes a little more work to remove than a washable high-street formula. Short, fine lashes can find the large brush unwieldy.

Strengths

  • Serious volume from a single coat
  • Hourglass brush lifts and fans the lashes
  • Holds a curl well when layered over a primer
  • A little goes a long way, so the tube lasts

Weaknesses

  • Clumps at the tips if you layer too fast
  • The large brush is tricky on short or hooded lashes
  • Needs a proper oil-based remover

Best for length and separation: Benefit They're Real! Magnet

Benefit They're Real! Magnet Mascara

Best for length and separation

Rating 4.5/5

They're Real! Magnet is built for length and separation rather than bulk. The domed brush has a narrow tip that gets into the inner corners and the short lashes at the outer edge, coating them so the whole lash line looks longer and more even. The formula is thin enough to comb through without dragging, which makes it a good choice if you hate the spider-leg look. It layers well over a primer and keeps lashes lifted through a working day. The trade-off is volume: it lengthens and defines but does not thicken dramatically, so if you want a full, dense fan of lashes you will need something heavier.

Strengths

  • Precision tip reaches corner lashes
  • Separates without leaving spikes or clumps
  • Builds length with two to three thin coats
  • Good over a lash primer for extra hold

Weaknesses

  • Modest volume compared with a volumising formula
  • Premium price for an everyday mascara

Best for sensitive eyes: Clinique High Impact

Clinique High Impact Mascara

Best for sensitive eyes

Rating 4.0/5

Clinique's mascaras are the ones to look at if your eyes water, itch or you wear contact lenses. High Impact is ophthalmologist-tested and formulated with sensitive eyes in mind, with a traditional bristle brush that coats lashes evenly without making them stiff. It gives soft, natural-looking volume — more 'awake' than 'false lash' — and it comes off easily with warm water and a cleanser, which matters if you do not want to tug at your lash line every night. A waterproof version exists for weddings, holidays and hay-fever season. It is not the formula for anyone chasing maximum drama, and very oily lids may find it transfers by the end of a long day.

Strengths

  • Comfortable on sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Natural volume that still looks like your own lashes
  • Removes easily without harsh rubbing
  • Waterproof version available for occasions

Weaknesses

  • Not dramatic enough for a full evening look
  • Can transfer on very oily lids

Best for precise definition: L'Oréal Paris Telescopic

L'Oréal Paris Telescopic Mascara

Best for precise definition

Rating 4.0/5

Telescopic's comb-style wand is the reason to buy it: the short, well-spaced teeth grip each lash and pull it upward, giving clean length and separation rather than bulk. It is especially good on short, straight or downward-growing lashes, and on the lower lashes and inner corners where a fat brush makes a mess. The formula is thin and buildable, so you can layer two or three coats without the tips sticking together. It is not a volumising mascara; if your lashes are sparse you will want something with more body, and the small brush takes a little longer to work through a full lash line.

Strengths

  • Comb wand separates lashes cleanly
  • Excellent on lower lashes and inner corners
  • Buildable length without clumping
  • Budget-friendly and widely available

Weaknesses

  • Very little volume
  • Small wand makes a full lash line slower to do

How to choose a mascara

  • Match the wand to your lashes. Short or straight lashes do better with a slim, tapered or comb brush; long lashes can carry a big hourglass brush without it ending up on your eyelids.
  • Decide on the finish first. Lengthening formulas are thinner and separate well; volumising formulas are thicker, deposit more pigment and clump more easily.
  • Think about your lids and your day. Oily lids, watery eyes, gym sessions and British weather all push you towards waterproof or tubing formulas.
  • Be honest about removal. Waterproof mascara needs an oil-based cleanser or bi-phase remover. If you know you will not bother, buy washable.
  • Check the ingredients if your eyes react. Ophthalmologist-tested and fragrance-free formulas are the safer starting point for sensitive eyes.
Wand shape and size
5.0/5
The single biggest factor in the finish. A tapered or comb wand separates; a fat hourglass brush builds volume.
Finish and buildability
4.0/5
Do you want one dramatic coat or three thin, controllable ones? Thicker formulas give more per coat but clump sooner.
Wear and smudging
5.0/5
Oily lids and watery eyes need a waterproof or tubing formula, plus a little powder under the eye.
Ease of removal
4.0/5
Washable formulas come off with warm water; waterproof ones need an oil-based cleanser.
Eye sensitivity
4.0/5
Contact lens wearers and reactive eyes should start with an ophthalmologist-tested formula.
Washable
Water-based, easy to remove, but smudges with tears, sweat and humidity.
Waterproof
Oil-based, holds a curl through rain and swimming, needs an oil cleanser to remove.
Tubing
Polymers form removable tubes around each lash; resistant to smudging and slides off with warm water.
Fibre-enhanced
Contains tiny fibres that add length or volume; more prone to flaking by the end of the day.
Lash primer
A white or tinted base coat that adds bulk and grip; needs covering fully with mascara.

Application tips that make any mascara work harder

  • Curl first, then coat. Heated or manual lash curlers work best on clean, dry lashes; mascara applied before curling can stick to the curler and pull lashes out.
  • Wipe the wand. Take off the excess on the edge of the tube or a tissue — most clumping starts with too much product on the brush.
  • Wiggle at the root. Press the wand into the base of the lashes and wiggle side to side before sweeping up; that is where volume and lift come from.
  • Layer while tacky. Apply the second coat before the first has fully dried, or you will get flakes rather than a smooth build.
  • Comb through. A clean spoolie run through the tips separates lashes and removes any clumps before they set.
  • Soak, do not scrub. Hold a soaked cotton pad over the eye for a few seconds so the formula dissolves, then wipe downwards gently.

The verdict

Mascara FAQs

How often should I replace my mascara?
Most brands advise replacing mascara about three months after opening. If it smells different, has thickened or starts flaking, replace it sooner — old formula is a common cause of eye irritation.
Why does my mascara smudge under my eyes?
Usually it is oil from your lids or from a rich eye cream, or a formula that stays soft. Set the under-eye with a light powder, give eye cream time to absorb and try a waterproof or tubing formula.
Is waterproof mascara bad for my lashes?
Not in itself, but it demands a gentler removal routine. Soak a cotton pad in an oil-based remover, hold it over the closed eye, then wipe down; tugging at dry lashes is what causes damage.
Do lash primers actually make a difference?
They can. A primer adds bulk and grip, which helps fine or sparse lashes hold more mascara and stay lifted. Tinted primers are easier to cover completely than white ones.
Can I use the same mascara on my lower lashes?
Yes, but use just the tip of the wand and a light hand. A slim comb or precision wand gives far more control on the lower lash line than a large volumising brush.

Related articles