Skip to content
Makeup to Makeout
Menu
Smiling woman holding makeup brushes on both sides of her face

Best Eyebrow Pencils for Every Brow Type and Budget

Five eyebrow pencils that draw real hair strokes without looking drawn on, plus how to match your shade and when a fine tip beats an angled nib.

Which eyebrow pencil should you buy?

An eyebrow pencil has one job: to make gaps, thinning patches and over-plucked tails look as though they were always there. The pencils that do it best share three things — a tip thin enough to place product exactly where the gap is, a wax-to-powder texture that grips skin without going shiny, and a shade that sits in the same undertone as your brow hair.

Below are five worth your money, from a high-street bargain to the prestige classic, with what each one is genuinely good at and where it falls down.

The picks at a glance

The three fine-tip pencils, side by side

Pencil

Anastasia Brow Wiz

Tip
Ultra-fine retractable, soft and waxy
Formula and finish
Waxy powder that blends into a soft, matte fill
Shade range
The widest here, with strong ash, taupe and grey-brown options
Wear
Good, though it can fade on oily skin by evening
Best for
Natural hair strokes and precise tails
Price bracket
Premium

Benefit Precisely, My Brow

Tip
Fine retractable, slightly firmer so it holds a sharper point
Formula and finish
Firmer wax that sets down and resists smudging
Shade range
Broad, with warm and cool shades for most hair colours
Wear
Benefit describes it as waterproof with up to 12-hour wear — the toughest here
Best for
Long days, humidity and oily skin
Price bracket
Premium

NYX Micro Brow

Tip
Fine retractable, softer and a little more crumbly
Formula and finish
Soft wax; blends well but needs setting
Shade range
Modest, strongest in brown, ash and black
Wear
Fine for a normal day; the first to budge in heat
Best for
A first pencil, a handbag spare or a travel buy
Price bracket
High street

Shaped tips and sharpenables compared

Pencil

Hourglass Arch Brow

Tip
Angled wedge that draws a wide stroke or a thin edge
Formula
Waxy powder, soft and buildable
Tools included
Built-in spoolie on the other end
Speed
Fastest full-brow fill of the five
Best for
Full but patchy brows that need evening out

Laura Mercier Eye Brow Pencil

Tip
Fine wooden tip that you sharpen yourself
Formula
Firm wax that holds a crisp line
Tools included
No spoolie — pair it with a brow brush and a sharpener
Speed
Slower; built for drawing individual hairs
Best for
Sparse brows and a sharply defined tail

Best overall: Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

Best overall

Rating 4.7/5

Cult status comes down to the tip: ultra-fine, retractable and soft enough to smudge, so you can draw individual hairs and then blur them with the spoolie into something that reads as your own brow rather than a drawn line. It is also the most forgiving pencil here to use on bare skin — the waxy-powder texture grips without skipping over dry patches.

The shade range is the widest of the five, with proper ash, taupe and grey-brown options for anyone whose brows read cool rather than warm. Wind it up a millimetre at a time: the tip is delicate and snaps if you over-extend it.

Why it wins

  • Ultra-fine tip draws believable hair strokes and a sharp tail
  • Waxy-powder formula blends into a soft, natural fill
  • Widest shade range of the five, including cool ash and grey-brown tones
  • Built-in spoolie means no extra tools to carry

Watch out for

  • The tip snaps if you wind too much product out
  • You will finish it faster than a thicker pencil
  • Can fade on very oily skin by the end of the day

Best for long wear: Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil

Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil

Best for long wear

Rating 4.5/5

If your makeup has to survive a commute, a gym session or an oily T-zone, this is the one to reach for. The tip is firmer than Brow Wiz and the formula sets down instead of staying creamy, and Benefit describes it as waterproof with up to 12-hour wear — the firmer, faster-setting wax is what makes that claim credible.

The trade-off is forgiveness. Because it grabs the skin quickly, a heavy hand looks drawn-on, and once it sets it will not blend as readily. Work in short, light strokes and soften the inner corners with the spoolie immediately.

Strengths

  • Waterproof formula designed for heat, humidity and long days
  • Firm tip holds its point for crisp hair strokes
  • Broad shade range with both cool and warm options
  • Spoolie on the end for softening the edges

Weaknesses

  • Firmer texture is unforgiving if you press hard
  • Sets quickly, so blend before it grabs
  • Costs more per pencil than the high-street picks

Best budget buy: NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil

NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil

Best budget buy

Rating 4.2/5

The high-street answer to the fine-tip pencil: same shape, same spoolie, a fraction of the price. The tip is fine enough for hair strokes along the length of the brow and the wax blends into a soft shadow, which makes it the sensible first buy if you are not yet sure a pencil suits you.

What you lose is staying power and shade nuance. The formula is softer, so it fades over a long day and can go patchy over a rich moisturiser or an oil-based SPF. Dust the brow area with a little powder first and it behaves far better.

Strengths

  • Fine tip and spoolie for high-street money
  • Soft enough to blend into a natural shadow
  • Easy to find on the high street — a good handbag or travel spare
  • Solid range of brown and ash shades

Weaknesses

  • Fades faster, especially on oily skin or in heat
  • Softer formula can go patchy over rich skincare
  • Tip blunts and can snap with heavy use

Best for filling fast: Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil

Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil

Best for filling fast

Rating 4.4/5

A wedge-shaped tip rather than a point, and that is the whole idea. Lay the wide edge along the brow and two strokes add density across the arch; turn it onto the narrow edge for the tail. It is the fastest full-brow fill of the five, which is why it suits brows that are already full but patchy or thinning at the edges.

It is not a hair-stroke pencil. Used heavily, the waxy powder goes blocky and flat, so keep the pressure light and blend with the spoolie. It is also the priciest here, which is hard to justify unless speed is the thing you are buying.

Strengths

  • Angled tip fills a full brow in a couple of strokes
  • Waxy powder adds density without looking flat
  • Spoolie blends the edges in seconds
  • Good for brows that are patchy rather than sparse

Weaknesses

  • Too thick for drawing individual hairs
  • Over-applying makes brows look blocky
  • The most expensive pencil of the five

Best for hair strokes: Laura Mercier Eye Brow Pencil

Laura Mercier Eye Brow Pencil

Best for hair strokes

Rating 4.3/5

An old-fashioned wooden pencil with a firm wax core, sharpened to a needle point. That firmness is the appeal: the point does not collapse as you press, so you can place short strokes exactly where the gaps are and define a tail without any drag.

The catch is maintenance. You need a sharpener, there is no spoolie on the end, and every sharpen removes product, so it disappears faster than a twist-up. The shade range is smaller than the fine-tip rivals too, so if you can get to a counter, swatch it on the brow itself.

Strengths

  • Firm wax holds a sharp point for precise hair strokes
  • Matte finish that never looks shiny
  • Excellent for a defined tail or a gap where skin shows
  • A little goes a long way

Weaknesses

  • Needs sharpening and has no built-in spoolie
  • Firmer texture takes longer to blend
  • Smaller shade range than the retractable rivals

How to choose an eyebrow pencil

  • Match the brow hair, not the hair on your head. If you dye your hair darker, do not automatically buy the matching pencil: brows usually stay a shade or two lighter. Look at them in daylight and decide whether they read cool (ash, grey, taupe) or warm (golden, auburn, red).
  • Fine tip for precision, angled tip for speed. A point draws hairs and defines a tail; a wedge fills a whole brow in two strokes. Work out which of those you actually need.
  • Texture decides the finish. Waxy-powder blends into a soft fill, firmer wax holds a crisp stroke and lasts longer, and anything very creamy slides off oily skin.
  • Check the other end. A spoolie is not a luxury — it is what stops pencil looking like pencil. If the pencil has none, buy a brush.
  • Be honest about wear. A pencil with strong staying power is harder to blend, so pick based on your skin and your day, not on the swatch alone.
  • Do not buy black. Unless your brows are genuinely black, charcoal or dark brown looks softer and far more natural.
Ultra-fine retractable tip
Best for hair strokes, gaps and a defined tail. Needs a light hand and a spoolie to soften.
Angled or wedge tip
Best for filling a full brow quickly; turn the narrow edge for the tail.
Wooden pencil
Firm wax, sharpenable to a precise point. Slower, but very controllable.
Waxy-powder formula
Blends into a soft shadow and suits bare or lightly powdered skin.
Firm, water-resistant wax
Holds a crisp line and resists humidity; less forgiving to blend once set.
Tip precision
5.0/5
A fine tip draws hairs; a fat one draws blocks. This is the biggest single difference between pencils.
Shade and undertone match
5.0/5
The right depth with the wrong undertone reads orange or grey. Match the brow hair in daylight.
Staying power
4.0/5
Oily skin, humidity and long days need a firmer, more water-resistant formula.
Blendability
4.0/5
A waxy-powder texture smudges into a soft fill; too firm and it sits on top of the skin.
Value per pencil
3.0/5
Fine tips run out quickly, so price matters more here than it does with a brow powder.

Getting the shade right

  • Fair brows that vanish in photos: go a shade lighter than you think and stay in the ash, taupe and cool-brown end. A warm brown turns ginger on pale skin.
  • Brunette: a mid-brown with a cool undertone covers most cases; choose a warmer brown only if your hair has red in it.
  • Auburn and red hair: an auburn or warm-brown pencil, never anything orange-red.
  • Black hair: charcoal or dark brown rather than jet black, which looks harsh in daylight even applied lightly.
  • Grey or white brows: a soft ash-taupe fills the gaps without leaving a dark shadow behind.

Pencil, powder or pomade?

A pencil is the tool for definition: gaps, a tail that has thinned, the lower edge of the arch. Powder gives a softer all-over tint and suits brows that are sparse across the whole shape rather than patchy. A pomade or tinted gel is the choice for a bold, laminated look and for holding hairs in place.

Most people get the best result from two of the three: pencil for the shape, then a clear or lightly tinted gel brushed through to marry the pencil with the hair. If your brows are very sparse, a pencil first and a matching powder pressed over the top gives density without a flat, painted look.

A 30-second brow routine

  1. Brush the brows up with a spoolie and look at where the gaps actually are — most people fill the front far too heavily and leave the tail thin.
  2. Set the shape first: light strokes along the lower edge and through the tail.
  3. Fill in the direction the hair grows, pressing lightest at the front of the brow.
  4. Blend the whole brow with the spoolie, then set with a clear or tinted gel.

If you only have time for one step, make it the tail. A defined tail and a soft front is what makes a brow look drawn by hand rather than stencilled.

The verdict

Frequently asked questions about eyebrow pencils

Can you use an eyebrow pencil over foundation?
Yes, but set the brow area with a light dusting of powder first. A waxy pencil can skate over a dewy base, and cream foundation makes it smudge rather than grip.
How long should an eyebrow pencil last?
A fine retractable tip used daily tends to run out within a few months, because so little product sits in the barrel. Sharpenable wooden pencils disappear faster still, since every sharpen takes some with it; thicker wedge pencils last longest.
Is it better to go a shade lighter or darker than your brows?
Lighter, almost always — and never darker than your natural brow hair. An over-dark pencil flattens the brow and looks heavy in daylight, even when the application itself is light.
Do I need a brow gel on top of the pencil?
Not always, but a clear or tinted gel holds the hairs in place and blends pencil into hair. It matters most on brows that grow in different directions or have a few stubborn, wiry hairs.
Can a pencil help if my brows are very sparse?
Yes. Draw short strokes in the direction of growth rather than one continuous line, then soften with a spoolie. Pressing a matching powder over the top adds density where skin shows through.

Related articles