Skip to content
Makeup to Makeout
Menu
Woman holding spoon over eye

Best Under-Eye Concealers: 5 Picks Worth Buying

We compare five under-eye concealers, from a full-coverage high-street buy to a hydrating pick for dry, lined skin, with shade and crease tips.

The quick answer

Under-eye concealer is the product where "best" depends almost entirely on what your dark circles are made of and how much moisture your skin holds. A matte, full-coverage formula that flattens pigmentation on oily skin will look chalky and flat on dry, lined under-eyes; a dewy, hydrating formula will slide off a combination complexion by mid-afternoon.

Here is the short version:

  • Best overall: NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer — buildable medium coverage, a radiant finish and a genuinely wide shade range.
  • Best budget: Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer — full coverage for very little money, at its best on oily or younger skin.
  • Best for quick brightening: Maybelline Instant Anti-Age Eraser Eye Concealer — sheer, fresh and the fastest of the five to apply.
  • Best for dry or mature skin: Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer — creamy and dewy, and far kinder to fine lines.
  • Best for long wear: Fenty Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Concealer — matte, full coverage that stays where you put it.

How the five compare

Coverage, finish and the main caveat for each concealer.

Concealer

Best for

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
Best overall
Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer
Best budget
Maybelline Instant Anti-Age Eraser Eye Concealer
Best for quick brightening
Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer
Best for dry or mature skin
Fenty Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Concealer
Best for long wear

Coverage and finish

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
Medium and buildable; radiant
Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer
Full; matte-leaning
Maybelline Instant Anti-Age Eraser Eye Concealer
Sheer to light; fresh
Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer
Medium; dewy
Fenty Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Concealer
Full; matte

Keep in mind

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
Can settle into fine lines if you apply too much
Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer
Small shade range that skews light to medium
Maybelline Instant Anti-Age Eraser Eye Concealer
Won't hide deep pigmentation on its own
Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer
Pricey, and can travel on oily skin
Fenty Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Concealer
Needs a hydrating eye cream underneath

The best under-eye concealers, reviewed

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer

Best overall

Rating 4.6/5

The one we would hand to almost anyone. Radiant Creamy sits in the sweet spot between coverage and slip: it lifts bluish-brown shadows without the flat, painted-on look, and it blends with fingers, a sponge or a small brush. The doe-foot applicator gives you control, so you can tap on a thin layer and build only where you need it. It works as a face concealer too, which softens the mid-range price. On very dry under-eyes it can settle into fine lines by late afternoon — prep with a hydrating eye cream and use less than you think you need.

Why it wins

  • Buildable medium coverage that still looks like skin
  • Radiant finish that brightens rather than flattens
  • Wide shade range with clear, readable undertones
  • Doubles up as a concealer for blemishes

Where it falls short

  • Can crease on dry or heavily lined under-eyes
  • Costs considerably more than high-street options

Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer

Best budget

Rating 4.3/5

A genuine British high-street staple and the closest thing to a full-coverage under-eye concealer at pocket-money prices. The formula is thick, opaque and matte-leaning, so a tiny amount covers strong pigmentation and redness, and the small doe-foot reaches right into the inner corner. The trade-off is texture: on dry or mature skin it can look flat and emphasise lines, and the shade range is narrow, which is its biggest limitation. On oily, younger skin with deep shadows, few things beat it for the money.

Why it wins

  • Serious coverage from a very small amount
  • Very affordable and easy to find on the high street
  • Matte finish that holds up on oily skin

Where it falls short

  • Limited shade range
  • Can look dry or cakey on mature under-eyes
  • Thick texture needs a light hand

Maybelline Instant Anti-Age Eraser Eye Concealer

Best for quick brightening

Rating 4.2/5

The twist-up cushion applicator makes this the fastest concealer in the bathroom: click, dab, blend, done. Coverage is sheer to light with a fresh, slightly luminous finish — ideal on days when you want to look awake rather than made up. It is formulated with the under-eye area in mind rather than as a general-purpose concealer, and the cushion is gentle on thin skin. It won't erase deep navy circles on its own, and the sponge tip divides opinion: some love the effect, others find it unhygienic and impossible to clean properly.

Why it wins

  • Quickest to apply — good for rushed mornings
  • Light, brightening finish that suits no-makeup makeup
  • Cushion tip is gentle on thin under-eye skin

Where it falls short

  • Not enough coverage for strong dark circles
  • The sponge applicator can't really be washed
  • Narrow shade range

Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer

Best for dry or mature skin

Rating 4.4/5

If your under-eye area is dry, lined or simply thinner with age, this is the one to test. The texture is creamy and emollient, it blends out without dragging the skin, and the finish is dewy rather than powdery — much kinder to fine lines than a matte formula. Coverage lands at medium: enough for shadows and redness, not for very deep pigmentation, though it layers well over a colour corrector. The catch is price and slip. On oily skin or in humid weather it can travel, and a light dusting of powder keeps it in place.

Why it wins

  • Hydrating, creamy texture that flatters fine lines
  • Dewy finish without looking greasy
  • Blends easily with fingers, no brush required

Where it falls short

  • Expensive
  • Can shift on oily skin without powder
  • Medium coverage only

Fenty Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Concealer

Best for long wear

Rating 4.3/5

A matte, high-coverage formula built for long days, humid weather and oily skin. It sets down quickly and stays put, which makes it the pick for weddings, double shifts and anyone whose concealer vanishes by early afternoon. The shade range is one of the widest in the category, with a real spread of undertones rather than ten versions of beige. Under the eyes that matte grip is a double-edged sword: it can look dry on crepey skin and clings to flakiness, so it needs a hydrating eye cream underneath and a light hand.

Why it wins

  • Very long-wearing and transfer-resistant
  • Full coverage for strong dark circles
  • Exceptionally wide shade range

Where it falls short

  • Matte finish can look dry on lined under-eyes
  • Needs careful prep on dehydrated skin

How to choose an under-eye concealer

Judge a concealer on the finished under-eye, not on the swatch. These are the factors that actually change the result:

  • Skin type first. Oily skin and hooded lids do better with a matte or satin formula that sets; dry, thin or mature skin needs creaminess, or the concealer will catch on every line.
  • Coverage in layers. A buildable medium formula is more forgiving than a full-coverage one, because you can add a second thin layer only where the shadow is darkest.
  • Undertone, not just depth. Blue-purple circles and brown circles need different correctors, and a concealer with the wrong undertone will look grey or orange however well it matches on paper.
  • Finish. Radiant and dewy formulas brighten dry skin but can highlight texture; matte formulas blur but can look flat in daylight.
  • Applicator. A doe-foot wand gives precision; a cushion tip is quicker but harder to keep clean; a squeeze tube wastes least product.
  • Shade testing. Swatch under the eye and along the jaw in daylight — never on the back of your hand, which is a different colour from your face.
Coverage without heaviness
4.5/5
The best formulas hide shadow with one thin layer rather than a thick, visible one.
Crease resistance
4.5/5
Look for something that sets slightly but stays flexible; fully matte formulas crack, fully dewy ones slide.
Hydration on dry under-eyes
4.0/5
Emollient textures flatter fine lines; they rarely suit oily skin.
Shade range and undertone accuracy
4.5/5
A wide range with clear warm, neutral and cool options matters more than a long list of shades.
Speed and ease of application
3.5/5
Worth weighting heavily if you do your makeup on the train.
Value for money
3.5/5
Concealer is used in tiny amounts, so a mid-range tube often outlasts the cheap one you over-apply.

Colour correcting and shade matching

Most disappointment with under-eye concealer comes down to colour, not formula.

If your circles look blue or purple — the thin-skin, visible-vein kind — a peach or salmon corrector underneath does more than any amount of extra concealer. Apply a tiny amount, tap it out until it disappears, then go over it with a concealer that matches your skin tone.

If your circles are brown, which is common on medium and deep skin tones, a peach or orange-based corrector used sparingly evens out the colour. Pale, ash-toned concealers will look grey on top of it, so keep the concealer close to your own depth and warmth.

Two rules that save time: go no more than one shade lighter than your foundation under the eyes, and check the result in daylight near a window before you commit. A concealer that looks perfect in a warm bathroom mirror can flash back white in photographs.

How to stop under-eye concealer creasing

Creasing is usually a quantity problem before it is a formula problem.

  • Hydrate, then blot. Eye cream first, then press off any excess with a tissue so the concealer has something to grip.
  • Use a dot per eye. Start with half of what feels right; you can always add, and most creasing comes from a layer that was too thick to set.
  • Tap, don't drag. Your ring finger or a damp sponge presses product into the skin; a dragging brush pushes it into the lines you're trying to hide.
  • Build in thin layers. Two sheer layers sit better than one heavy one, particularly on the inner corner where the skin is thinnest.
  • Powder selectively. A light dusting of finely milled powder only where you actually crease beats baking the whole under-eye, which dries out mature skin.
  • Leave the very inner corner alone. A little shadow there is normal and reads more like a face than a completely even plane does.

The verdict

Under-eye concealer: common questions

Should under-eye concealer be lighter than my foundation?
One shade lighter at most, and only if you are happy to set it. A concealer that is too light creates a pale ring that shows in daylight and flashes white in photos. For strong circles, a peach or salmon corrector under a concealer that matches your skin is more convincing than a lighter shade.
Can I use the same concealer under my eyes and on spots?
Usually yes, but the two jobs want different finishes. Under the eyes you want something creamy and blendable; on blemishes you want coverage that sets. Matte, long-wear formulas handle both well, while very dewy ones tend to slide off spots.
Do I need a separate eye cream?
It helps more than upgrading your concealer does. Dehydrated under-eyes make even expensive formulas look patchy, and a simple hydrating eye cream applied a minute before makeup is the cheapest way to improve the finish.
How often should I replace under-eye concealer?
Follow the period-after-opening symbol on the tube, which is typically six to twelve months for a wand concealer. If the texture separates, the smell changes or it starts irritating the skin, replace it regardless of the date, and never share a sponge-tip applicator.
Is a colour corrector the same as a concealer?
No. A corrector is a peach, salmon or orange-toned product designed to neutralise the colour of dark circles; a concealer matches your skin tone and covers. You can wear a corrector alone under light base makeup, or layer concealer over it for stronger coverage.

Related articles