Skip to content
Makeup to Makeout
Menu
Close-up profile of a woman's bare cheek and jaw

How to Choose Concealer Colour: Match Undertone and Job

Match concealer to your undertone and to the job in hand — dark circles, spots or redness — using a daylight test, corrector guidance and quick fixes.

The short answer

Concealer colour is decided by two things, and only one of them is your skin: the job you want it to do.

If you're covering a spot or redness, you want a concealer that disappears into the skin around it — the same depth and the same undertone, give or take half a shade. If you're covering dark circles, you're usually cancelling a colour first (blue, purple, grey-brown), and that takes a corrector with a peach, salmon or orange tone, depending on how deep your skin is.

The mistake most people make is buying one very light concealer and using it everywhere. On a spot it draws a pale dot. Under the eye it can turn grey within an hour. Treat under-eye concealing and spot concealing as two separate jobs with two separate shades, and the question answers itself.

What you need before you start

A few things make the difference between guessing and actually knowing:

  • Clean, bare skin on one side of the face, or your usual foundation on, so you can see how a concealer behaves over your base.
  • Daylight. A window beats any shop mirror or bathroom light.
  • A hand mirror, so you can check the jaw and neck from the side.
  • Two or three candidate shades, plus a corrector if dark circles are the target. One swatch tells you very little.
  • Cotton buds and a tissue for wiping between tests.
  • Twenty minutes to let the swatches sit — many formulas darken or turn warmer as they dry and mix with your oils.
  • Your usual skincare underneath. A concealer that sits well on bare skin can behave differently over a rich moisturiser or an acid serum.

How to choose your concealer colour, step by step

  1. 1. Decide exactly what you're covering

    Under-eye darkness, a single spot, redness around the nose, pigmentation, or a mix. Each has a different target shade, so decide before you start swatching — it stops you being talked into the wrong product.

  2. 2. Find your depth first

    Ignore the shade name and hold the tube against your bare jaw. Does it read lighter, darker or level with your skin? Depth is the easy part: fair, light, medium, tan, deep, rich. Get that roughly right before you think about undertone.

  3. 3. Then work out the undertone

    Compare the swatch with your jaw and neck in daylight. Pink or rosy is cool, golden or peachy is warm, a mix is neutral, and a green-grey cast is olive. Olive skin usually suits neutral-to-olive shades; anything too pink or too peach will pull orange or ashy on you.

  4. 4. Pick the right product family for the job

    A skin-matching concealer for spots and redness. A colour corrector plus a skin-matching concealer for dark circles — corrector first and thin, then a concealer matched to the skin around the eye, not to the circle itself.

  5. 5. Swatch in the correct place

    Jawline for a face match. Over the darkest part of the circle for a corrector. On the edge of a spot, blended outwards, for a blemish concealer. The under-eye area is thinner and paler than the jaw, so a shade that vanishes on your jaw can look heavy under the eye.

  6. 6. Let it sit, then check again in daylight

    Wait 15–20 minutes and look by the window. If it has gone orange, grey or chalky, the undertone is wrong or the shade is too light. Check the neck from the side too — a visible line at the jaw means the depth is off.

  7. 7. Wear it for a few hours before committing

    Ask for a sample where that's offered, or test on half the face and get on with your day. Oil, warmth and the products underneath all change how a concealer reads by mid-afternoon.

  8. 8. Re-check in artificial light and on camera

    Shop lighting flatters almost everything. Look at your face under a bathroom bulb and in a phone photo with the flash off. Very pale, high-white-pigment concealers can flash back as a grey patch.

Matching by job

The same skin can need three different concealer shades depending on what you're covering.

What you're covering

Under-eye circles

Depth to aim for
Half a shade to one shade lighter than your skin — no more
Undertone to look for
Peach or salmon for blue-purple; orange-red on deep skin
Texture that works
Lightweight and flexible, with little drag on thin skin
Where to place it
On the darkness only, tapped thin

Blemishes and spots

Depth to aim for
Exactly your skin depth
Undertone to look for
Slightly yellow-leaning shades cancel redness as they cover
Texture that works
Higher pigment and a drier set so it stays put
Where to place it
A pinpoint on the spot, blended at the edges

Redness and flare-ups

Depth to aim for
Exactly your skin depth, over a corrector if needed
Undertone to look for
Green corrector first, then a skin-matched concealer
Texture that works
Thin corrector layers, then concealer only on the red
Where to place it
Small amounts on the red areas, not the whole face

How to read your undertone

Warm and cool describe what sits under the surface colour of your skin, and they matter more than depth once you're close to a match. In daylight, hold a white tissue against your bare jaw and neck and look at what the skin does next to pure white:

  • Cool: pink, red or bluish tones come through.
  • Warm: golden, yellow, peachy or honey tones come through.
  • Neutral: a balance — neither obviously pink nor obviously golden.
  • Olive: a green-grey cast, often over a warm or neutral depth. Foundation tends to look orange or ashy on olive skin.

The most reliable test isn't a chart, it's how base products behave on you. If foundations consistently look pink on your skin, you're probably warmer than you think. If they look orange, you're probably cooler or more olive. If they look grey, the depth is right and the undertone is wrong.

What each corrector colour does

Peach
Cancels blue-purple under-eye circles on fair to light skin. Sheer and forgiving.
Salmon
For medium skin and brownish-purple circles; warmer than peach without tipping into orange.
Orange or red-orange
For deep skin tones and very dark brown or purple circles. A tiny amount goes a long way.
Green
Neutralises redness — spots, rosacea flare-ups, redness around the nose. Keep it sheer or it turns grey.
Lavender or lilac
Brightens sallow, yellow-grey dullness. Easy to overdo, so use it on small areas only.
Yellow
Softens mild purple bruising and faint darkness, and works as a brightener on medium skin.
When to skip a corrector
If your circles are mostly shadow from a hollow or a fold, no colour will cancel them. Placement and a light-reflecting concealer do more.

If your skin is deep or rich

Deeper skin has more visible red, golden and orange undertones, and the under-eye area is often several shades darker than the cheek. That combination is where pale concealers fail hardest: a shade that looks fine on the jaw can turn a chalky grey under the eye.

  • Choose a corrector with real warmth — salmon, orange or red-orange — rather than peach, and use it only on the darkness.
  • Then conceal with a shade matched to the skin immediately around the circle, not to the cheek, and not several shades lighter.
  • Look within the deep and rich section of a range rather than the lightest shade available, and check the undertone rather than the number.
  • Test on the under-eye itself. A swatch on the jaw will almost always look too light for the eye area.

Application, so the colour reads true

A correct shade can still look wrong if it's applied badly.

  • Prep first. Concealer over flaky or dehydrated skin catches on texture and looks paler than it is. Moisturise and let it sink in.
  • Corrector first, thin, only on the colour. Sheer layers, tapped in. A thick corrector layer forces you to pile concealer on top.
  • Tap, don't drag. A fingertip or a small damp sponge keeps the product where you put it; dragging shifts it and sheers it out unevenly.
  • Apply blemish concealer after foundation, pinpoint it on the spot, then blend only the edges. Blending across the centre removes the coverage you just added.
  • Skip the big under-eye triangle. Drawing a lighter shade down the cheek is what makes it obvious. Keep it on the darkness.
  • Powder only where you crease. Heavy powder lightens and dulls the shade; a light tap of finely milled powder on the inner corner is usually enough.

What commonly goes wrong, and how to fix it

Problem

Why it happens

Under-eye looks grey
The concealer is too light or too cool for the colour you're covering
Turns orange by lunchtime
Oxidation, or a warm shade on cool or olive skin
The spot looks more obvious
The shade is lighter than the surrounding skin, or there's too much product
Cakey and cracked by the afternoon
Dry skin, too much powder, or a matte formula on thin under-eye skin
Pale patch in photos
High white pigment, or a shade that's too light for you
Obvious line at the jaw
Depth or undertone is off, usually too light

The fix

Under-eye looks grey
Add a peach or salmon corrector underneath and bring the concealer closer to your skin depth
Turns orange by lunchtime
Test for 20 minutes before buying and again after a few hours; go neutral rather than golden
The spot looks more obvious
Match the surrounding skin exactly and use a pinpoint, not a dot
Cakey and cracked by the afternoon
Hydrate first, use thinner layers and powder only where you actually crease
Pale patch in photos
Check with a phone photo in daylight and go a touch deeper and warmer
Obvious line at the jaw
Blend down the neck and re-check in daylight from the side

Safety and easy-to-miss details

  • Patch test new eye-area products on the inner forearm for a couple of days if your skin is sensitive or you have known allergies.
  • Don't use concealer or corrector on broken or infected skin — a stye, an infected lash line, a cold sore or an open spot.
  • Respect the period-after-opening symbol, usually six to twelve months for eye concealers, and bin anything that has separated, changed smell or changed texture.
  • Don't share applicators, and don't dip a wand back into the tube after it has touched a spot.
  • Remove everything at night. Leftover under-eye product plus rubbing is a common cause of irritation.
  • Know when it isn't a makeup problem. Persistent dark circles, a new or changing mole, one-sided swelling or pigmentation that's spreading needs a pharmacist or GP, not a corrector.

Common questions about concealer colour

Should concealer be lighter than my foundation?
For spots and redness, no — match it to the skin around the area. For under-eyes, half a shade to one shade lighter is the useful range; anything more reads as a pale or grey patch in daylight.
Do I need both a corrector and a concealer?
Only if your circles are strongly blue, purple or brown. The corrector cancels the colour and the concealer covers what's left. On mild darkness, one well-matched concealer is often enough.
Can I use concealer instead of foundation?
On small areas, yes — a spot, redness around the nose, a patch of pigmentation. All over the face it tends to look patchy, and it won't match your neck.
How do I choose a concealer shade online?
Start from a foundation shade you know suits you, stay in the same undertone family, and judge by swatch photos shown on a range of skin tones rather than the product image. Check the returns policy before you order.
Does concealer go before or after foundation?
Corrector goes first, on bare or primed skin. Concealer goes on after foundation for spots and redness, so you can see how much is still showing and use less.

Related articles